The duality of self and other in the book “Al-Etibar” in light of Henri Bajou’s theory

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

1 PhD student of Arabic language and literature, Faculty of Humanities, Bu- Ali Sina University, Hamedan, Iran

2 Assistant Professor, Department of Arabic Language and Literature, Faculty of Humanities, , Bu- Ali Sina University, Hamedan, Iran

3 Professor, Department of Arabic Language and Literature, Faculty of Humanities, , Bu- Ali Sina University, Hamedan, Iran

Abstract

Imagery or surology is one of the branches of comparative literature and studies the manifestations of imagery in literary works, including the image of the self and the other. The image is about a geographical environment, a historical event, a culture, customs, traditions, and different groups that have a symbolic language and linguistic characteristics. In the study of image, concepts and components such as stereotypes, bias, image, and representation are introduced. One of the theories in light of which we can study the image of the self and the other is the theory of Henri Pajou, the French visual artist, who believes that the image has three directions: the superior direction or positive distortion, the inferior direction or negative distortion, and the horizontal direction or neutrality. He is a great writer and poet who lived in Shizer region shortly before the crusades, and his book Al-Etibar presents a detailed and amazing image of different social and political classes and strata, including the image of the author himself and his family. , different tribes of Arabs, Fatimids, Ayyubids, Christian invaders and other groups. This research aims to investigate the duality of the self and the other in the Book of Al-Etibar through a descriptive-analytical method and based on the theory of
 surology, and to answer the basic question of what are the types of images of the self and the other and their examples in this book?
Keywords: Comparative literature, surology, self and other, Osama bin Munqidh, Al-Etibar.
Introduction
Surology is one of the most important subjects of literary research in the field of comparative literature. This science examines the image of oneself and others in literary works. The present study aims to examine the image of me and another in the book of Al-Etibar. This book is full of various religious, political, social and cultural knowledge. Osama's memoirs (1095-1188) were included in this book, a valuable message for future generations; And I played a long way in narrating many beautiful pictures and special sights of different countries, traditions, customs and living utensils, and shed light on the history of these countries. The book Al-Etibar contains a lot of political, geographical, historical, social, cultural and religious information, and therefore it is suitable for studying the image and manifestations of the self and the other in it. In this book, Ibn Munqidh presents a clear image of the different classes and groups by carefully looking at different angles of the social and political life of the people of his time. The importance of this research lies in the fact that it attempts to study the types of images in the book Al-Etibar and through it to identify Osama’s point of view and his portrayal of the groups and classes he talked about, because this book is considered one of the most important sources related to the issues and events associated with the Crusades and the power of Christians in Jerusalem and their injustice towards the different groups, as it also talked about their social, political and cultural behavior.
Materials & methods
This research was conducted using the descriptive analytical approach and by collecting the necessary information about the subject and analyzing it in light of Henri Pajou’s theory of the image.
Results
After studying the duality of self and other in the book Al-Etibar, we can come up with the following results:

Osama described what he saw and heard in his travels and memories, without any favoritism towards any person or group. What distinguishes his presented images is frankness and expression of details; as he describes the events that took place in the Crusades in detail and talks about the different races and nationalities participating in these wars.
The self models in the book Al-Etibar are the Muslim Arabs and the other models are the Christian Crusaders. When talking about each group, Osama tries to be neutral and present their news, events and customs as they are, and acts with integrity and honesty.
Osama has adopted a fair position towards the crusader enemy and has had a realistic view far from contempt or bigotry in depicting their customs and character and morals. This approach made his travelogue have a lot of historical value and through it one can learn about the facts of this period of Muslim history and their resistance against the advance of the Crusaders.

Keywords

Main Subjects


 

دوگانگی من و دیگری در سفرنامه اعتبار اسامه بن منقذ بر پایه نظریه هنری پاژو

جلال خوشوقت[1]

سید حسن فاتحي [2]

سید مهدي مسبوق [3]

 

چکیده

تصویرشناسی یا صورولوژی یکی از شاخه­های ادبیات تطبیقی ​​است و به بررسی جلوه­های تصویر در آثار ادبی از جمله تصویر خود و دیگری می پردازد. تصویری از یک محیط جغرافیایی، یک رویداد تاریخی یا یک فرهنگ، آداب و رسوم، سنت­ها و مقوله­های مختلف است که دارای زبان نمادین و ویژگی­های زبانی هستند. در مطالعه تصویر، مفاهیم و مؤلفه هایی مانند کلیشه، سوگیری، تصویر و بازنمایی معرفی می شوند. یکی از نظریه­هایی که در پرتو آن می توان تصویر خود و دیگری را بررسی کرد نظریه هانری پاژو، هنرمند تجسمی فرانسوی است که معتقد است تصویر دارای سه جهت است: جهت بالا یا تحریف مثبت، جهت پایین یا تحریف منفی و جهت افقی یا خنثی بودن. بر اساس این نظریه، کتاب الاعتبار نوشته اسامه بن منقذ (488-584)، انتخاب شد. او نویسنده و شاعر بزرگی است که اندکی پیش از جنگ های صلیبی در منطقه شیزر می زیست و کتاب الاعتبار او تصویری دقیق و شگفت انگیز از طبقات و اقشار مختلف اجتماعی و سیاسی ارائه می­دهد که از آن جمله تصویر خود نویسنده و خانواده­اش، قبائل مختلف اعراب، فاطمیان، ایوبیان، مهاجمان مسیحی و سایر گروه­ها است. این پژوهش بر آن است تا با روش توصیفی تحلیلی و در پرتو تصویرشناسی به بررسی دوگانه­ی خود و دیگری در کتاب الاعتبار بپردازد، و به این پرسش اساسی پاسخ دهد که انواع تصویر خود و دیگری و مصادیق آن در این کتاب چیست.

کلیدواژه­ها: ادبیات تطبیقی، تصویرشناسی، من و دیگری، اسامه بن منقذ، سفرنامه الاعتبار.

 

[1]. دانشجوی دکتری زبان و ادبیات عربي، دانشکده علوم انسانی، دانشگاه بوعلی سینا، همدان، ایران mohammad_erfan90@yahoo.com 

[2] استادیار گروه زبان و ادبیات عربی، دانشکده علوم انسانی، دانشگاه بوعلی سینا، همدان، ایران (نویسنده مسئول) s.fatehi@basu.ac.ir 

[3] استاد گروه زبان و ادبیات عربی، دانشکده علوم انسانی، دانشگاه بوعلی سینا، همدان، ایران smm@basu.ac.ir 

تاریخ دریافت: 17/11/1402، تاریخ پذیرش: 02/04/1403

 

Books
 Ibn Manzoor, M. (2000 AD), Lisan al-Arab, first edition, Beirut: Dar Al-Fikr.[in Arabic]
 Ahmad Melhem, I. (2016 AD), literary text analysis, three critical entries, first edition, Jordan: Irbid.[in Arabic]
 Osama bin Munqidh, A. (2003 AD), consideration, investigation: A K Al-Ashtar, second edition, Beirut: The Islamic Office.[in Arabic]
 Al-Isfahani, A. (1375 BC), Khreida Al-Qasr and Al-Asr Newspaper: Department of the Levant Poets, investigation: M B Al-Athari, Iraq: Al-Majma Al-Alami Press.[in Arabic]
 Badawi, A A. (1983 AD), Literary Life in the Age of the Crusades in Egypt and the Levant, second edition, Cairo: Dar Al-Nahda.[in Arabic]
 Bouhalais, S. (2009 AD), The Image of the Self and the Other in the Poetry of Mostafa Mohamed Al-Ghamary, Algeria: Haj Lakhdar University.[in Arabic]
 Bahi, E, D.T., The psychological trend in the study of literature and criticism, D.B. [in Arabic]
 Bishwa, C and A M. Rousseau. (2001 AD), Comparative Literature, translated by A Abdel Aziz, Cairo: Anglo Egyptian Library. [in Arabic]
 Al-Gohari. (2008 AD), Al-Sahih Dictionary, third edition, Dar Al-Ma'rifah, Lebanon: Beirut. [in Arabic]
 H K, Muhammad Moazzam. (2009 AD), Osama bin Munqith: His Life and Literary Traces, The Islamic Scientific University. [in Arabic]
 Hammoud, M. (2000 AD), Applied Approaches in Comparative Literature, No. I. Damascus: Union of Arab Writers. [in Arabic]
 Khalaf Kamel, E, D.T., The Semiological Direction and Criticism of Poetry, Sudan: Dar Farha. [in Arabic]
 Ragab, M. (1994 AD), Women's Philosophy, second edition, Egypt: Dar Al-Maaref. [in Arabic]
 Zakar, S. (1995 AD), An Introduction to the History of the Crusades, Part One, Damascus. [in Arabic]
 Suleiman, N. (1985 AD), self-awareness and the world, studies in the Arabic novel, first edition, Syria: Dar Al-Hiwar.[in Arabic]
 Ashour, F H. (1988 AD), Muslim Jihad in the Crusades: Fatimid, Seljuk and Zangi eras, Beirut: Al-Risala Foundation.[in Arabic]
 Al-Arousi Al-Matawi, Muhammad (1954 AD), The Crusades in the East and Morocco, Tunisia: Dar Al-Kutub Al-Sharqiya.[in Arabic]
 Issa, Muhammad, (2003 AD), the psychological reading of the Arabic literary text, Damascus: Arab Writers Union.[in Arabic]
 Katsav, Walid (2009 AD), Methods of Modern Literary Criticism, second edition, Damascus: Dar Al-Fikr.[in Arabic]
 Louis Maalouf. (1991 AD), Al-Munjid in Language and Media, 31st Edition, Dar Al-Mashreq and the Oriental Library, Lebanon: Beirut.[in Arabic]
 Mostafa, I and H Abdel-Qader, A H Zayat, M A Najjar. (2013 AD), The Intermediate Dictionary, the Islamic Library for Printing and Publishing: Turkey.[in Arabic]
 Maalouf, A. (1998 AD), The Crusades as the Arabs saw them, translated by Afif Damascene, second edition, Beirut: Dar Al-Farabi.[in Arabic]
 Al-Makki,TA.(1987 AD), Comparative Literature, Its Origins, Development and Methods, Cairo: Dar Al-Maaref.[in Arabic]
 Henry Bajo, D. (1997), General and Comparative Literature, translated by G Sayed, Damascus: Arab Writers Union.[in Arabic]
 Thesis
 Boualem, S. (2015 AD), the determinants of the ego and the other in the new Algerian novel, a university thesis submitted for a doctorate degree in Arabic literature, Algeria: University of Oran. [in Arabic]
 
Mohammadnoor, Z and Sarah Tamkeen Shaddad. (1987 AD), the psychological approach in literary criticism, is part of the requirements for obtaining a bachelor's degree in Arabic language and literature, University of Al-Qadisiyah. [in Arabic]
 Taree’ah, A. (2019 AD), Manifestations of Sorrow in the Poetry of Osama Bin Munqith, a thesis submitted for obtaining a doctorate degree, M Kheidar University in Sikra: Faculty of Arts and Languages. [in Arabic]