Cognitive Stylistics of Political Conceptual Metaphors in Al-Nazarat by Manfaluti with Emphasis on Lakoff's Theory (Case Study: Stories of Al-Hurriyah and Ayna Al-Fazilah)

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

1 Ph.D. candidate of Arabic Language and Literature, Bu Ali Sina University, Hamedan, Iran.

2 Professor of Arabic Language and Literature, Bu Ali Sina University, Hamedan, Iran.

3 Professor of Arabic Language and Literature, Bu Ali Sina University, Hamedan, Iran

10.30465/afg.2025.50281.2153

Abstract

Conceptual metaphor is one of the important areas of cognitive studies, in which a set of systematic correspondences between the source and target domains aligns the conceptual elements of the source domain with those of the target domain. Manfaluti presents the political themes of the stories "Al-Hurriyah" and "Ayna Al-Fadilah" through metaphorical conceptualizations based on the author’s personal, historical, and cultural experiences, causal relationships, and similarities between the concepts, as well as the actions and functions of the two domains.
The present study, employing descriptive and content analysis methods with a cognitive approach, examines the most important stylistic features of conceptual metaphors. It investigates how concepts derived from the source domain are used to concretize the target domain in Manfaluti's aforementioned stories and determines his style through the relationships between the source and target domains. The findings of the research show that in conceptualizing political concepts within the target domain, such as politics, law, despotism, and freedom, Manfaluti resorts to several source domains with specific features.
Among the prominent features of his style is the ability to conceptualize abstract concepts as tangible phenomena, which makes the deep concepts of the text easier for the audience to understand. For example, he uses the source domain of "false and unreal phenomena" to conceptualize "legal-political tools," "lost commodity" to conceptualize "virtue in political gatherings," and the source domains of "life," "light," "vast field," "breeze," and "appearance of a valuable thing" to conceptualize "freedom." Additionally, he uses "chains," "loss of wealth," "puppet," and "hiding a valuable thing" to conceptualize the target domain of "lack of freedom."
The basis of Manfaluti's metaphorical conceptualizations lies in the author’s personal, historical, and cultural experiences, causal relationships, and the similarities and correspondences between the two concepts and the actions and functions of the two domains.
Keywords: Cognitive stylistics, political conceptual metaphors, Mustafa Lutfi Al-Manfaluti, Al-Nazarat, the stories Al-Hurriya and Ayna Al-Fazila.
Introduction:
Cognitive stylistics is a novel approach in stylistic studies that developed and flourished during the first decade of the 21st century. This approach allows for the examination and analysis of texts through various stylistic layers and with a fresh perspective. It not only focuses on the relationship between linguistic choices, stylistic influences, and the reader's interpretation of the text, but also links these stylistic choices and prominent linguistic patterns to issues of mind and cognition.
One of these stylistic layers is the rhetorical layer, where metaphor plays a fundamental role. In traditional rhetoric, metaphor was often analyzed mainly from an aesthetic viewpoint. However, in the 1980s, emerging perspectives challenged classical linguistic theories of metaphor. In his article "The Contemporary Theory of Metaphor," contemporary American cognitive linguist George Lakoff critiqued the classical view that considered metaphor merely a linguistic phenomenon rather than a concept rooted in thought.
Among the contemporary literary figures who have conveyed their views and worldview through the use of cognitive metaphors is Mustafa Lutfi Al-Manfaluti. Therefore, the present study, employing a descriptive-analytical approach, aims to identify the key stylistic features, merits, and techniques of Al-Manfaluti in his use of cognitive political metaphors in the short stories "Al-Hurriyah" and "Ayn Al-Fazilah."
Materials & Methods
The data collection method in this article is library-based, and the research approach is descriptive-analytical, employing cognitive stylistics. The collected data is classified and processed using content analysis. Initially, the fundamentals of cognitive stylistics, along with various opinions, viewpoints, and related areas, are explained. Then, examples of conceptual metaphors and their various domains are extracted from the short stories "Ayn Al-Fazilah" and "Al-Hurriyah" in Al-Nazarat. The data is analyzed and evaluated, leading to the identification of the author’s unique and distinctive style.
discussion & result
 Manfaluti represents a generation that lived under the rule of dictators and autocrats, who, in their effort to maintain power and control over the country, consolidated their authority by stripping various segments of society of their freedoms, thus reshaping the society according to their own desires. This situation became a driving force behind his work, inspiring his style to reflect the essence of political thought. He used his writing to defend the freedom of his oppressed and suffering nation, as well as all Arab nations. Through a distinctive style, he expressed a wide range of political views, employing cognitive metaphors, including structural metaphors, ontological metaphors (such as personification, materialization, and container metaphors), and directional metaphors. With subtlety and clarity, he revealed both the visible and hidden aspects of the hostile world controlled by the ruling powers over society.
Conclusion:
 One of Manfaluti's stylistic features in presenting political concepts is his ability to connect each target domain to multiple source domains, depending on his perception and ideology. He also expands the scope of each source domain to encompass a variety of target domains. The foundation of Manfaluti’s metaphorical conceptualizations is sometimes grounded in his personal, historical, and cultural experiences, sometimes in cause-and-effect relationships, and at other times in similarities, where correspondences and shared elements between two concepts, as well as their actions and functions, are established.

Keywords

Main Subjects


سبک­شناسی شناختی استعاره­های مفهومی سیاسیِ النظرات اثر منفلوطی با تکیه بر نظریۀ لیکاف

(مورد مطالعه: داستان­های الحریة و أین الفضیلة)

پروین یوسفی[1]

مرتضی قائمی*[2]

سید مهدی مسبوق[3]

چکیده

استعارۀ مفهومی یکی از حوزه­های مهم مطالعات شناختی است که در آن مجموعه­ای از تناظرهای نظام­مند میان مبدأ و مقصد وجود دارد که عناصر مفهومی حوزۀ مبدأ را بر عناصر مفهومی حوزۀ مقصد منطبق می­سازند. منفلوطی مضامین سیاسی داستان­های «الحریة» و «أین الفضیلة» را از طریق مفهوم­سازی­های استعاری ارائه کرده است که بنیان آنها تجربۀ فردی، تاریخی و فرهنگی خود نویسنده، رابطۀ علی و معلولی و تشابه در وجود تطابقات و اشتراکات بین دو مفهوم و کنش­ها و عملکردهای دو حوزه بوده است. پژوهش حاضر با شیوۀ توصیف و تحلیل محتوا و با رویکرد شناختی، به بررسی مهم­ترین ویژگی­های سبکی استعاره­های مفهومی و مفاهيم بهره­برداری شده­ از حوزۀ مبدأ به هدف عینی­سازی حوزۀ مقصد در دو داستان مذکور منفلوطی پرداخته و سبک او را از خلال روابط میان دامنۀ مبدأ و گسترۀ مقصد تعیین نموده است. یافته­های پژوهش نشان می­دهد که منفلوطی در مفهوم­سازی هر یک از مفاهیم سیاسی حوزۀ مقصد از قبیل سیاست، قانون، استبداد، آزادی و...  به چندین حوزۀ مبدأ با ویژگی­های خاص متوسل شده است؛ از جمله ویژگی­های برجستۀ سبک او توانایی در مفهوم­سازی مفاهیم انتزاعی به مثابۀ پدیده­های عینی است که که فهم مفاهیم عمیق متن را برای مخاطب آسان‌تر کرده است. از حوزۀ مبدأ «پدیدۀ دروغ و غیر واقعی» برای مفهوم­سازی «ابزارهای حقوقی سیاسی»، از «کالای گمشده» برای مفهوم­سازی «فضیلت در مجامع سیاسی»، همچنین حوزه­های مبدأ «زندگی»، « نور»، «میدان وسیع»، «نسیم» و «پدیدار شدن شیء باارزش» را برای حوزۀ مقصد «آزادی». از «غل­وزنجیر»، و مانند این­ها بهره گرفته است. همچنین استفاده از تصاویر همپایه و مکرر و مترادف برای مفهوم­سازی در حوزه سیاست و نقد سیاسی از ویژگی­های استعاره­های منفلوطی است. انتخاب نوع حوزه­های مبدأ در استعاره­های منفلوطی ، عصبانیت و نارضایتی شاعر نسبت به اوضاع سیاسی را به تصویر می­کشد. بنیان مفهوم­سازی­های استعاری منفلوطی نیز گاه تجربۀ فردی، تاریخی و فرهنگی خود نویسنده، گاه رابطۀ علی و معلولی و گاه تشابه در وجود تطابقات و اشتراکات بین دو مفهوم و کنش­ها و عملکردهای دو حوزه بوده است.

واژگان کلیدی: سبک­شناسی شناختی، استعاره­های مفهومی سیاسی، مصطفی لطفی منفلوطی، النظرات، داستان­­های الحریة و أین الفضیلة.

 

[1] دانشجوی دکتری رشتۀ زبان و ادبیات عربی دانشگاه بوعلی سینا، همدان، ایران. . p.yousefi@ltr.basu.ac.ir

[2] استاد گروه زبان و ادبیات عربی دانشگاه بوعلی سینا، همدان، ایران. m.ghaemi@basu.ac.ir. (نویسنده مسئول) 

[3] استاد گروه زبان و ادبیات عربی دانشگاه بوعلی سینا، همدان، ایران. smm@basu.ac.ir

تاریخ دریافت: 15/9/1403، تاریخ پذیرش: 18/12/1403

 

  1. Books

    1. Fakhouri, H. (2008). History of Arabic Literature, Tahran: Publishing Tos. [in Arabic].
    2. Fotuhi, M. (2011). stylistics; Theories, approaches and methods, Tehran: Sokhan Publishing. [in Persian].
    3. Hamilton, G. (1371). Modern Arab Literature, translated by Yaqub Azhand, second edition, Tehran: Information Publications. [in Persian].
    4. Kovecses, Z. (2014). Practical Introduction to Metaphor, Shirin Pourabrahim Translation, First Edition, Tehran: Post Publications . [in Persian].
    5. Kovecses, Z. (2015). Metaphor in World Culture and Diversity, Translated by Nika Entezam, First Edition, Tehran: Siahrood Publications. [in Persian].
    6. Kovecses, Z. (2016). Language, Mind and Culture, First Edition, Translated by Jahanshah Mirza Beigi, Tehran: Agah Publications . [in Persian].
    7. Kovecses, Z. (2016). Where the metaphors come from, the textual knowledge of the metaphor, the translation of Jahanshah Mirza Beigi, Tehran: Agah Publications. [in Persian].
    8. Lakoff, G. (2005). The War of the Caliphate or the metaphors that kill, Abdul Majid Jahfa and Abd al -Ilah Salim, 1st floor, Morocco: Dar Toubkal. [in Persian].
    9. .• Likaf, G. & Mark, J. (2004). the metaphors we live By, translated by Hajar Agha Ebrahimi, Tehran: Agah Publications. [in Persian].
    10. Al - Manflouti, M. (2014). Al -Nazrat, First Edition, Volumes 1 and 2 and 3, Beirut: Publishing the Scientific Books House. [in Arabic].
    11. Al - Nassaj, H. (1990). The Development of the Art of the Short Story in Egypt, Cairo: Al-Gharib Library. [in Arabic].
    12. Safavi, K. (2013). An Introduction to Cognitive Meaning, Tehran: Surah Mehr Publications. [in Persian].
    13. Al - Ziyat, A. H. (1999). History of Arabic Literature, Beirut: Dar Al-Marafah. [in Arabic].

    Theses

    1. Dahman, O. (1391). Metaphors and Literary Discourse: A Contemporary Cognitive Approach, Thesis for Ph.D Degree, Republic of Algeria: Mouloud University. [in Arabic].
    2. Kurtos, Jamila (2011), Metaphor in the Light of Interactive Theory, Why Did You Leave the Horse Alone by Mahmoud Darwish as a Model, Master’s Thesis, Faculty of Arts and Humanities, Mouloud Mammeri Tizouzou University, Algeria. [in Arabic].

    Journals

    1. Hajizadeh, M. & Khaleghi, A. (2013). "Thematic reflection of the Holy Quran in the works of Mostafa Lotfi Manfaluti", Quarterly Journal of Quranic and Hadith Sciences, Volume 46, Number 1, Pages 41-63. Doi: 22067/NAQHS.V46I1.13707.[in Persian].
    2. Hosseini, M. B. (2013). "Criticism of the woman in the eyes of Manfaluti and Al Ahmad", journal of Arabic Literature, Volume 3, Number 3, pp. 281-306. Doi: 1001.1.22519238.1390.3.3.12.0 . [in Persian].
    3. Mokhtari, Q. (2013). "Comparative analysis of story elements in the short stories of Manflouti and Jalal Al Ahmad", journal of Persian Language and Literature Interpretation and Analysis (Dehkhoda), Volume 4, Number 14, Pages 193-210. [in Persian].
    4. Nemati Qazvini, M. & Narges, A. (2014). "Social and cultural critique of Al-Ahmed and Manflouti's views on women's issues", Journal of Women in Culture and Art, 7th Volume, Number 2, Pages 269-293. Doi:22059/jwica.2015.57580 . [in Persian].
    5. Saber Abdul Aziz, Saber, Perceptual metaphors and periods in political discourse, Journal of Arabic Studies, Darul Uloom College, Jamiat al-Mania.[in Arabic].
    6. Seifi, T.(2015). "Manifestation of the Holy Qur'an and Noble Hadiths in the Works of Mostafa Lotfi Manfaluti", two quarterly journals of Qur'anic research in literature, 7th year, number 2, Pages 126-140. Doi: 1052547/koran.7.2.126. [in Persian].