Structural analysis of the ode "Gharsialurka" by Badr Shaker Al-Siyab (based on Lucien Goldman's theory of developmental structuralism)

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

1 Assistant Professor of Arabic language and literature, Payam Noor university,tehran,iran,

2 Associate Professor of Arabic language and literature, University of Sciences and Education of the Holy Quran, azarbijan gharbi, iran.

3 Doctoral student of Arabic Language and Literature, Shahid Beheshti University,Tehran, iran

10.30465/afg.2023.44633.2055

Abstract

Structural criticism is one of the newly established methods in literary criticism and a method within literature that takes its linguistic and aesthetic foundation from the nascent science of linguistics, especially the views of Swiss linguists, Ferdinand de Saussure and Russian formalists. The whole effort of the structural criticism method is to discover the general, mysterious and complex relationships of the structure of the literary work, which expresses states, thoughts, emotions, complex structures of linguistic, artistic, literary and aesthetic systems. They have defined three fundamental functions for such a critical method; Extracting the components of the structure of the work, establishing the relationship between the components of the structure of the work and showing the implication in the overall structure of the work.The ode "Garcia Lorca" is the work of contemporary Iraqi poet "Badr Shaker Al-Sayab" who wrote it in memory of the Spanish poet and writer Federico Garcia Lorca. In this ode, the poet has used the world dream method of "Lucien Goldman", a Romanian sociologist and literary critic. It is a dream that was born from a social structure and born from developmental structuralism. The main argument of developmental structuralism is that no part has meaning by itself, but each part should be considered in relation to its other parts and finally the whole system. In other words, in the analysis of a poem from the point of view of structural criticism, its components and elements should not be analyzed separately; But its overall structure should be considered. This type of structuralism believes that artistic invention is the embodiment of world dreams that is born from the social status of a class, a specific group or a group of people.
Therefore, it can be said that structuralism, which is considered by Goldman, on the one hand, seeks to examine the components and elements that make up a work, and on the other hand, it tries to reach the overall concept and meaning of the work by communicating between the components. In this critical method, the structural critic presents a final overview of its technical and artistic structure by analyzing the expressive, literary and speech elements of the text. Although the manner of Lorca's death and murder by the fascists has had an effect on the attention of Sayab and Arab poets in general on his literature and poetry, what increases this effect even more is the reflection of Islamic and Arabic symbols and Especially Andalusia is in his poems. Another fact about Lorca becoming a praiseworthy figure among contemporary Arab poets was his social and revolutionary role. A role that was reflected in his poems and eventually led to his murder. Arab poets considered him a revolutionary poet in the true sense of the word. In García Lorca's ode, Sayab tries to present an image of his ideal poet based on his socialist thought and perspective. A poet who is humanistic and has a social duty and should think about the society and the hungry. Sayab tries to bring up concepts that are consistent with Lorca's views and thoughts and address them in his obituary. he wants to create a match between Lorca's perspective and social constructions and the constructions formed in the work, and this is what Lucien Goldman does in the topic of developmental structuralism and the poet's outlook and worldview, refers to it. Sometimes the poet completes the structure of the ode by creating a quasi-imaginary atmosphere and paying attention to small elements. It is as if the poet, by creating this pseudo-imaginary space, is looking for his global dream, which is indeed spring greens, sea water, fertile pastures and full of goodness and blessings, and the fight against poverty in the world. A space that moves forward with role-playing and centrality (sail). Concepts such as water, which is the source of being alive and pure, and a storm that can wipe away evil and wickedness from the earth, and a fire that can ignite inside an oven and feed the hungry It shows the worldview of the poet and expresses the compatibility and equivalence of socio-economic issues at the time of the creation of the work with the structure of the work and their effects on each other. From a symbolic point of view, the poet has been able to express one of his goals, which is to move forward and hope for the future, by using the word "sail". He has well understood that the Arab nation needs hope, and it is this hope that forces people to continue despite all the hardships. So by bringing the word "sail" at the end of the ode and repeating it a lot, he is trying to promise his audience the forward movement.This article seeks to answer the following questions by applying the descriptive-analytical method and using library resources and applying this critical method to this poem: To what extent does the poet and his style of expression in the poem correspond to Lucine Goldman's style? What are the manifestations of the poet's dream of reforming Arab society in the poem? The main objective is a structural analysis of the poem and proving a hypothesis explaining that the poet's dream is the same dream that Lorca had, which is to change the human being, and thus to change the world. The results indicate that this ode is based on a constructive and symbolic structure, and the poet uses the "Lucien Goldman" world dream method and dreams of a hero, whose main goal is to reform the Arab and global society. be The structure of the ode aims to express the dream role of the poet and his heroic and charismatic mythological role. By reflecting on the ode, we can conclude that the poet wants to modernize and manifest his role, which is the savior of the Arab people, by portraying and reinterpreting the role of Lorca in the society of his time.

Keywords

Main Subjects


تحلیل ساختاری قصیده­ی "غارسیالورکا" اثر بدر شاکر السیاب

(بر اساس نظريه­ی ساختارگرایی تکوینی لوسین گلدمن)

مصطفی جوانرودی* [1]

عسگر بابازاده اقدم**، امین شکوری***

چكيده  

نقد ساختاری یکی از روش های نقد ادبی است که پایه زبانی خود را از علم زبان شناسی، به­ویژه ديدگاه­هاي زبانشناس سوئيسي، فردينان دوسوسور گرفته است. تلاش نقد ساختاري بركشف روابط کلی و پیچيده ي ساختار اثر ادبی است. براي چنين روش نقدي سه کاركرد بنیادی تعریف نموده اند؛ استخراج اجزاء ساختارِ اثر، برقرار ساختن ارتباط بین اجزاء ساختارِ اثر و نشان دادن دلالت در کلیت ساختارِ اثر. قصيده ي "غارسيا لوركا" اثر "بدر شاکر السیاب" است که آن را در رثای شاعر اسپانیایی فدریکو گارسیالورکا سروده است. شاعر رویای جهانی "لوسين گلدمن"، منتقد ادبی رومانیایی را  بکار گرفته است. رويايي كه زایش یافته ی ساختار گرایی تکوینی است و اعتقاد دارد ابداع هنري، تجسم رؤياهاي جهاني است كه از وضع اجتماعي مردم متولد شده است. این مقال در پی آن است تا با روش توصیفی- تحلیلی به این پرسش­ها پاسخ دهد که آیا رؤياي اصلي شاعر به نوعی با رؤیای گارسیالورکا هم­خوانی دارد؟ و آیا شاعر با ترسیم یک نقش اسطوره­ای و قهرمان­زا برای خود در پی اصلاح جامعه­ی عربی و عالمی نو بوده است؟ نتایج حاکی از آن است که رؤیای شاعر همان رؤیایی است که لورکا در سر داشت: تغییر انسان و به تبع آن تغییر جهان.

 

كليد واژه­ها: ساختارگرایی تکوینی، بدرشاکر السیاب، غارسیا لورکا، لوسين گلدمن

 

[1] * استادیار گروه زبان و ادبیات عربی دانشگاه پیام نور، تهران، ایران (نویسنده مسؤول)mjavanrudy@pnu.ac.ir

** دانشیار گروه زبان و ادبیات عربی دانشگاه علوم و معارف قرآن کریم، آذربایجان غربی askar.babazadeh@gmail.com

*** دانشجوی دوره دکتری رشته زبان و ادبیات عربی دانشگاه شهید بهشتی، تهران parsa9878@yahoo.com 

تاریخ دریافت:12/06/1402، تاریخ پذیرش: 20/10/1402

 

 

 

  • book

    • Ahmadi, Babak (1380), Structure and Hermeneutics, Gam No Publications, third edition. [in Persian]
    • Azarnoush, Azartash (1381), History and Language of Arabic Culture, Samt Publications, third edition.
    • Al-Bakir al-Barazi, Majd Mohammad (1987), Fiqh al-Laghga al-Arabiya, Dar Majd Lawi, Vol. 1. [in Arabic]
    • Payandeh, Hossein (1382), Discourse of criticism, Tehran, Roznegar publication, first edition. [in Persian]
    • Selden, Raman; Peter Widdowson (1392), Guide to Contemporary Literary Theory, translator: Abbas Mokhbar, Tehran, New Design, fifth edition. [in Persian]
    • Al-Sayab, Badr Shaker (2000), Diwan, Volume 1, Beirut: Dar al-Awda. [in Arabic]
    • Ababneh, Sami (2004), the attitudes of the Arab critics in reading Al-Nus Shaari Al-Hadith, Manuscripts of Alam Al-Kutub Al-Hadith, Volume 1. [in Arabic]
    • Azzam, Muhammad (2003), Analyzing Al-Khattab al-Abadi, Damascus, Ittihad Al-Kitab Al-Arab leaflets. [in Arabic]
    • Fazl, Salah (1998), The Theory of Al-Banai in Al-Samat al-Adabi, Dar al-Sharooq, vol. 1. [in Arabic]
    • Kassab, Walid (2009), Methods of Al-Samat al-Adabi al-Hadith, Damascus, Dar al-Fakr, vol. 2. [in Arabic]
    • Columbus, Christopher (1381), the travelogue of Christopher Columbus in his first trip to the new continent, translated by: Mehyar Khalili and Zaheed Khalili, Qaseida Sera Publishing. [in Persian]
    • Goldman, Lucin and others (2013), an introduction to the sociology of literature (collection of articles), translator: Mohammad Jafar Poindeh, Tehran, Naqsh Jahan Mehr, second edition. [in Persian]
    • Goldman, Lucin (1382), formative criticism, translator: Mohammad Taghi Ghayathi, Negah Publications, first edition. [in Persian]
    • Wael, Seyyed Abdul Rahim (2009), Al-Taqli al-Baniwiyyah in Al-Samaat al-Arabi, Dar Al-Ilam and Iman for Publishing and Distribution, Volume 1. [in Arabic]

    Articles

    • Houri, Yair (2015), "Blessed is this death in your name: Federico Garcialorca in the poetry of modern Arab poets", translator: Mujib Mehrdad, Zemin magazine (politics, culture and philosophy). [in Persian]
    • Dossossur, Ferdinan (2002), General Linguistics Course, translator: Koresh Safavi, Hermes Publications, second edition. [in Persian]
    • Ravodrad, Azam (2014), Sociological Theories of Art and Literature, Tehran University Press. [in Persian]
    • Rajabi, Farhad; and Tahereh Shakuri (2014), "Study of the ideal consciousness of the poetry of Amal Dangul and Ismail Shahroudi based on the theory of Lucien Goldman's formative structuralism", Journal of the Iranian Society of Arabic Language and Etiquette, Volume 11, Number 34, pp. 59-81. [in Persian]
    • Satshani Kisheh Khale, Muharram; and Ali Nosrati Siahmezgi (2014), "Analysis of Massoud Saad Salman's City of Trade Union Chaos with Goldman and Bourdieu's Perspective", Journal of Sociology of Art and Literature, Volume 7, Number 2, pp. 28-43. [in Persian]
    • Shahmoradian, Kamran; and Shaisheta Ebrahimi (2013), "Classification and rooting of the stories of One Thousand and One Nights with the approach of criticizing Lucien Goldman's developmental structuralism", Annals of Persian Literature, Institute of Humanities and Cultural Studies, 5th year, no. Third, pp. 67-86[in Persian]
    • Shahbazi, Arzoo and others (2013), "Criticism of the Constructivism of the Novel Neighbors by Ahmad Mahmoud, Journal of Fiction Studies", Payam Noor University, Volume 2, Number 3, pp. 66-90. [in Persian]
    • Abdi, Salahuddin (2013), "A sociological approach to the works of Tahir Watar; a case study: the novel Al-Zelzal based on Lucien Goldman's model", Lasan Mobin, third year, new period , No. 7, pp. 207-235. [in Persian]
    • Fazli, Mahboud (1400), "Sociological criticism of the novel "Autumn is the last season of the year" with the approach of developmental structuralism", Journal of Literary Research, No. 73, pp. 97-121. [in Persian]
    • Fadzi, Hamid Reza; and Parisa Ghobadi Samian (2013), "Sociological examination of the novel "Mehreh Mar" by Mahmoud Etemadzadeh (Beh Azin) with an emphasis on the developmental constructivist approach", Journal of Sociological Studies, Volume 2, Number 5, pp. 65-86. [in Persian]